Holding a Smart Sweets sweet fish

Smart Sweets Review: Every Flavor Ranked

Smart Sweets are a lower-sugar alternative to traditional gummy treats. They come in many flavors including gummy bears, sweet fish, and rings. However, do they fit a keto lifestyle, and how do they taste? We’ll dive into both questions in this post.

Smart Sweets Ingredients

  • Prebiotic soluble fiber from tapioca
  • chicory root fiber

Smart Sweets carb count

Gummy BearsSour Gummy BearSweet FishPeach RingSour Blast Buddies
Total Carbs3335423342
Dietary Fiber2828222822
Net carbs5720520

Per Smart Sweets, peach rings and plain gummy bears have the best carb counts at 5 net carbs . each. Sour gummy bears are marginally worse at 7 net carbs for the entire bag. Sweet Fish and Sour Blast Buddies have substantially worse carb counts at 20 net carbs each.

This might be because both the Sour Blast Buddies and the Sweet Fish flavor container non-GMO soluble corn fiber as the first ingredient and allulose as the second, products not found in other flavors.

Are Smart Sweets keto?

Sadly, Smart Sweets are not strict keto.  This is because flavors like peach rings contain ingredients like rice flour and tapioca byproducts, and other isomalto-oligosacchharides.  When we first started the keto diet, one of our team members had a particular fondness for sweets. Most of the bags have anywhere from 33-45 carbs, with the large majority of those carbs beings counted as  dietary fiber. However this coincided with the development of Keyto –  our proprietary breath sensor. Each team member was taking up to 5-10 blood and breath tests a day. I noticed after consuming a bag, I’d be instantly kicked out of ketosis.

So we did some more investigating – looking mostly at the negative reviews on Amazon.
Review on Amazon of Smart Sweets

So we decided to test ourselves! I decided to consume an entire bag of gummy bears (because Science and sacrifice) to test the effect.

  • 8AM – No carb breakfast (coffee)
  • 11:00 AM PST – took first blood and breath tests, got a 1.2 mmol on blood test, and level 6 on the Keyto
  • 11:16 AM – finished the entire bag of plain Smart Sweets gummies (pink bag)
  • 12:01 PM – .5 mmol on blood test, and level 4 on the Keyto. Went from full ketosis to only light ketosis in just 45 minutes!
  • 2:05 PM – .2 mmol on blood test, and level 2 on the Keyto. Completely knocked out of ketosis in under 2 hours.

Summary: I ate one whole bag of Smart Sweets gummy bears and this is what happened:

TimeBlood: Beta-HydroxybutrateBreath: Keyto Level
Before eating1.2 mmol/LLevel 6
45 min after eating0.5 mmol/LLevel 4
1 hr 49 min after eating0.2 mmol/LLevel 2
  • Nutritional ketosis is greater than 1.0 mmol/L in blood, or Level 5 Keyto level in breath.
  • Light ketosis is 0.5-1.0 mmol/L in blood, or Level 4 Keyto level in breath.
  • Less than 0.5 mmol/L in blood, or lower than Level 4 Keyto level in breath is not in ketosis.

Disclaimer: These results were for one individual. Your results may vary depending on your level of fat adaptation and other factors. 

Unfortunately, it appears that eating too many Smart Sweets will kick you out of ketosis, and fast. Thus, if you are concerned about your ketone levels, we recommend not having this brand of treats.

For those that are looking for gummies that might be slightly better than traditional gummies, we’ve reviewed our favorite flavors below.

The best Smart Sweets flavor based of taste

Holding a Smart Sweets sweet fish

Sweet Fish (8/10)

  • Inspired by: Swedish fish
  • Piece count: ~13

These were by far the Mrs. favorite Smart Sweets of the bunch. Due to the size there’s much less pieces, but they’re chewier and have a “stick to your teeth” feeling that is similar to real Swedish Fish. What’s different is there’s definitely less of a springyness, which is common across all the Smart Sweets and most gummy replacements on the market. The flavor is also more akin to cherry than Swedish Fish but still very good and satisfying. I also like how it has more pieces than peach rings, below!

Smart Sweets peach rings flavor

Peach Rings (7.5/10)

  • Inspired by: classic Peach rings!
  • Piece count: ~10

These are a very, very close second for me. They are beautiful aesthetically and feel big and filling in the way the small bears do not.  While they don’t have the same “juiciness” that comes through in a classic peach ring, they’re still oddly satisfying and have a pleasing candy taste 🙂

Smart Sweets sour gummy bear flavor

Sour Gummy Bears (6/10)

  • Inspired by: gummy bears
  • Piece count: ~25

The sour gummy bears are also one of the first flavors released by Smart Sweets. We like these a little better than the non-sour flavor because they actually kind of taste like candy – vs. a more watered down fruit snack. The sour coating is also more pleasant than the coating on the sour blast buddies which is more chalky and thin. Overall these are a solid choice for quantity + taste.

Smart Sweets gummy bears

Gummy Bears (5/10)

  • Inspired by: gummy bears
  • Piece count: ~28

These are the classic gummies I believe Smart Sweets started out with. While there’s many pieces which makes knocking out an entire bag both deeply satisfying and gratifying, the flavors fall short for us overall. They’re sweet but not sickeningly sweet. Texture wise, they have a good springiness that gives them a better chew than the other specialty flavors like the peach rings. A solid classic if you prefer quantity and volume.

Smart Sweets sour blast buddies

Sour Blast Buddies (3/10)

  • Inspired by: Sour patch kids
  • Piece count: ~28-30

While I expected to love these candies, these were the least satisfying of the bunch. They’re just sour, without an interesting sugary flavor profile underneath and no interesting chew. Pass!

Where to buy Smart Sweets

Smart Sweets are widely available both in stores and online. They’re sold (and sometimes go on sale!) at health stores like Whole Foods, but they can also be purchased on the Smart Sweets site, Amazon and retailers like Thrive Market.

 

Alternatives to Smart Sweets

If you’re following the keto diet and want to find a suitable keto-friendly dessert or treat, we’re big fans of real dark chocolate with a high cocoa content.  Even though there are small amounts of sugar, these are arguably “healthier” and result in a  lower insulin response than many alternative sugars like those used in Smart Sweets. Try to find dark chocolates with at least 75-85% cocoa content and no more than 4G net carbs per serving.

Alternatively look for no-sugar added brands, which we’ll review soon!